When family relationships break down, tensions rise. In many parenting and divorce disputes, one party considers making secret recordings to capture threats, abuse, or manipulation. But before pressing record, it’s critical to understand the legal risks in Queensland.
Are Secret Recordings Legal in QLD?
Queensland operates under the Invasion of Privacy Act 1971. Generally, if you are a participant in a private conversation, you may lawfully record it. However, recording a conversation you are not part of can amount to a criminal offence.
Phone recordings can also trigger federal law under the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979, particularly where communications are intercepted without authority. The overlap between state and federal legislation makes legal advice essential.
Can Secret Recordings Be Used in Family Court?
Even if legally obtained, secret recordings are not automatically admissible. The Evidence Act 1995 allows courts to exclude improperly obtained evidence unless admitting it outweighs the undesirability of the breach (section 138). Judges also have discretion under section 135 to exclude evidence if it is unfairly prejudicial.
In parenting disputes, the Family Law Act 1975 requires the court to prioritise the child’s best interests. If recordings demonstrate family violence or risk of harm, they may carry weight. However, excessive or manipulative recording behaviour can damage credibility.
Risks of Recording an Ex-Partner
While making secret recordings may feel protective, courts often scrutinise the intent and context. Recording child changeovers, planting devices, or selectively editing conversations can be viewed negatively. In some cases, such conduct has undermined a parent’s case rather than strengthened it.
There are also disclosure obligations in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. If recordings exist, parties are generally required to disclose them. Failure to do so can result in serious consequences.
Practical Guidance Before Recording
If you are considering secret recordings in a Brisbane family law matter:
Confirm you are legally entitled to record
Avoid intercepting conversations you are not part of
Do not publish or share recordings publicly
Seek legal advice before relying on them in court
Strategic decisions about evidence should always be guided by professional advice, not emotion.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it legal to record someone in QLD?
Yes, if you are a participant in the conversation.
Can recordings be used in custody cases?
Possibly, subject to admissibility rules.
Are phone call recordings lawful?
They may engage both state and federal law.
Can illegal recordings still be admitted?
Sometimes, depending on judicial discretion.
Do I have to disclose recordings?
Yes, in most family court proceedings.
Can recording hurt my case?
Yes, especially if seen as manipulative.
Can I publish a recording online?
This may breach privacy laws.
Does the court prioritise child safety?
The best interests of the child prevail.
Should I get legal advice first?
Absolutely.
Contact Aylward Game Solicitors
Call: 07 3236 0001
Email: mail@aylwardgame.com.au
Article Source: Secret Recordings in Brisbane



